Entertaining stories, odd narration

I bought this despite mixed reviews having read a few of the stories, because there was no other full recording. I do agree that the narration is quite difficult to listen to - there are odd pauses and stresses in strange places in sentences, and pronunciation errors, not to mention some really terrible accents. This does make it quite hard to focus on, but the stories are still good and the narration wasn’t so bad as to detract from that too much.

One thing worth mentioning is that these stories are a product of their time, and do contain language and stereotypes which are wildly outdated and offensive nowadays. This can make for quite uncomfortable listening at times, but are reflective of the (unfortunately) common attitudes at that period.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Woeful

I liked the tv series so thought this would be the same.
Wrong.
The narrator has a monotone voice so all the participants sounded as Sean Connery or Micheal Cane were narrating.
May be just me, I found the whole of part 1 hard to follow, so the rest will not get a listen or mention.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Was ok until I heard some viscous anti semitism.

I liked the TV series so got this. Is sort of medieval, which I quite liked until I was shocked by some gratuitous antisemitism, quite unnecessary to the story and fairly out of context. I switched it off and won’t listen to the rest. Why hate such a tiny minority of people who have given the world some of the best principles of life. Father Brown having his principles from exactly the people he was despising. Doesn’t that go against honouring your father and mother?
It seems that it was ok to hate Jews but if it was said about black lives it would have banned!
2 stars because I like the TV series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Narration ruined it - and it really should have a warning as some of the racism is highly offensive

I’ve enjoyed tv and radio adaptations of Father Brown, so thought I’d give this a try.
Some of the descriptive writing, of landscape etc, is lovely; but the rest is a bit clunky. For example the writer doesn’t have to constantly refer to “the little priest” and comment on his size. This got very tiresome after a while.
The narrator is pretty awful; although in fairness to him, he’s quite good at accents.
Even by the standards of its time, the racism is pretty dreadful. If you are at all liable to be offended by such things, don’t listen to The God of the Gongs (Chapter 21 Book 2) it’s totally shocking.
All in all it was pretty disappointing on a number of levels.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Terrible Narrator

I'm struggling here. The narrator clearly hasn't familiarised himself with each story and continuously raises and lowers the pitch of his voice in the misguided notion that this obscures the fact that he is a poor actor reading his lines. It's distracting to hear this sing-song voice while trying to absorb the content. It's hard to judge the book itself because this repels engagement. That said, I'm not overly impressed, as it's way too far-fetched. The Father Brown character hardly appears in it so far (I'm up to chapter 6) and it really needs a human element to draw one in.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Monotonous narration

The stories might be ok, but it drags and you miss some of the story because you stop listening at times...feels so uninteresting due to the narrator not being up to scratch. Overall, downloaded 41 hours and listened to only 3 hours worth, one to avoid unless you only listen to one chapter every so often

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

hard work

not for me hard work I had to abandon it hope you find it better than I did

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Unfortunatly long, and poor

I was looking forward to this, I am a fan of classic writing. it is admittedly difficult to avoid comparing this to the excellent Sherlock Holmes, which could be unfair, but there is no comparison. I found the Father Brown to be painfully bad. The character himself is frustratingly cryptic to the point you would dismiss him because he can't make himself understood, he seems to enjoy being this way so comes across as arrogant. The stories do not offer any interest. by the time I stopped listening I found I was simply trying to 'Power through'. given the length of this I would recommend not investing your time.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

terrible narrator

Awful narrator, such a shame as loved reading them. Wouldn't recommend, unless could be read by another so disappointing

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

bloody marvelous

The father brown stories are an exceptional piece of work.
I'd advise everybody to give em a try.
they're very much of their time.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful