Satire of its time

Tongue in cheek manners satire. I will definitely listen again to extract my favourite quotes (e.g. on Foreigners).
I found the pauses between lines a little irritating- but maybe the text was printed this way, I have only listened to the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

I LOVED every word of this beautiful book!

"Elizabeth and Her German Garden" is another charming, hilarious, beautifully written work by Elizabeth von Armin and one of my favourite books of recent years. I was laughing and chuckling as I listened and was surprised by how current and relatable many of the author's observations are. Despite knowing absolutely nothing about gardening, I revelled in the descriptions of plants, gardening strategies, scenery and especially weather. A delicious treat of a book!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A great book narrated beautifully

The book is so funny and lovely and the narration is first class. I have thoroughly enjoyed this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

lovely

it's not enchanted April, but it is lovely, and Nadia May is a bit of a genius. good stuff.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

A wonderful insightful description of gardening and German life

Maggie

Being a gardener born of German parents this brought me a smile of recognition in every chapter. What delight to plan the huge plantations, to skirt around the immovable German traditions and to beat the Man of Wrath at his own game!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Charming story

A delightful listen, relaxing, and amusing.
So good to hear a woman making Independant decisions.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

UTTERLY WONDERFUL

If you need cheering up and are a gardener this witty charming book will lift your spirits

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

lovely story superbly narrated

The account of Elizabeth's garden, her joy in it, her sharp-eyed humour, all set in a time long-past, held together by a truly gifted narrator.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Delightful view of times gone by

This is not a very long book, but nevertheless a very pleasant look back to a more leisured lifestyle, and the frustrations and rewards of creating of a garden. Perfect bedtime listening, and with a first class narrator.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Timecapsule, enjoy it for what it is.

This was a very interesting book to listen to, but I think the description and the glowing reviews do not completely paint the whole picture. So I will add some observations.

Yes, it's a lovely book about gardening. It also has some VERY funny and witty moments and sentences. It is well written and reasonably well narrated. However, it is also a historical document written by a deeply entitled and spoiled woman. The people working around her estate are treated horribly; she thinks of them as halfwits. They are simply not 'human' to her. The disdain dripping from her upper class perch is hard to take in places. Animals are not treated well either. The Man of Wrath (her husband) is extremely unpleasant and delights in speaking about hitting women so that they'll know their place. Most of the latter half of the book is the writer and her best friend mocking a young woman who is staying with them for a few weeks. It is hardly about gardening at all anymore once she arrives.

All in all, this book is of interest for gardening enthousiasts who like some historical insight. Though funny in a sardonic way, Elisabeth is vey much a product of her time and class. I'm not really sure why some reviews describe this book as some tale about 'leisurely times'. To me it seems more like a document about horrific working conditions. How awful it must have been to work at that estate, commanded by a rich woman who thought she was above you just because of her accident of birth. Who gossips with her friend and gardens a bit, and somehow thinks this makes her more worthy or interesting than the workers who have minds like 'children' according to her. It's also telling that she does not do any of the actual gardening work. That is left for the men doing backbreaking labor and the women who are told to get back to work a day (sometimes hours!) after giving birth, because 'they are used to it and are simple creatures who experience these things differently than us'. Elizabeth basically just does the planning, and the purchasing of new plants. Then she walks around in the garden, pointing out things that need to be changed and entertaining guests.

Conclusion: it's not a relaxing tale about gardening at all. However, I did find it interesting as a historical document. I did like the (sometimes very catty) wit and the prose is quite good. So I don't rate it very low. But be aware that if you are looking for a lovely tale about gardens this might not be it.

The sound editing leaves in a lot of 'inhaling air before the next sentence' type of sounds, so if that is something you are sensitive to, beware.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful