cheesy but very funny

if you have never seen Up Pompeii or aren't a fan of Frankie Howerd or Carry On type humour, then you probably won't appreciate this. I actually came to this with low expectations but found myself laughing out loud several times at this!

"Frankie Howerd" is a very very good impression and it does sound as though you are actually listening to the man himself.

The plot, as always, is more or less irrelevant. The script does feel as though it could almost be an episode of the original series. The style and jokes are very similar (some jokes are identical!) as the TV show with a "slightly" ruder edge than the series.

But I thoroughly enjoyed this. There were two Up Pompeii TV sequels after the series ended, 1 in 1975 and one in 1990 (or 91?). But frankly, this is funnier and captures the style better than the Further Up Pompeii TV sequels managed.

Bit naughty, very UNPC, nostalgic and very funny. Definitely recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Madcap, Carry On-style nostalgia

I never saw the Frankie Howerd original series, sadly, but the style, the board and dirty humour, the theatre approach, it's both familiar and my sort of thing.

To listen to an homage, 50 years later, well, it felt like I could have been in the audience at the time. There may be references to texting and modern new-fangled technology, but I don't think the jokes have changed.

In fact, I'm pretty sure they were almost all recycled from their predecessors.

In Pompei, we are taken through a sex-crazed world of love affairs and subterfuge, of leering, lust and legs. By the Howerd-like narrator, Lurcio, who gets embroiled in his master's liaisons, and those of everyone else with too much time (and too many hormones) on their hands. Now is that their temperature rising, of that of the nearby volcano?

Loved listening to this, I felt nostalgic for a time I never lived through. I especially loved the moments of ad lib when actors forgot or missed lines and the cast has to compensate. But the whole thing is funny, from the Life of Brian-like names (Voluptua, Erotica) to the over-the-top lasciviousness and antiquated sexual attitudes.

Much fun. Not to be taken seriously. Or as historical fact.

With thanks to Nudge books for providing a sample Audible copy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A Pale Shadow of the Original

A nice idea in theory, but shockingly executed. The funniest bits are lifted word for word from the TV series and film, but with inferior delivery. The rest just felt like they were trying too hard to recapture the feel/jokes of the original without actually understanding what made it so good or having the comic timing to pull it off.

While the original was based around crude humour it was still limited by being a 60s/70s TV series and knew when to stop. Here there is a level of crudeness that would never have been allowed back then and unfortunately it feels totally out of place and for the most part isn't even all that funny.

David Benson, Fraser Hines and Madeline Smith are the best of the bunch and seem to be enjoying themselves, but the rest of the cast sound either wooden or just embarrassed to be there (or both).

If you're a fan of the original you might get a little bit of nostalgic enjoyment from this, but not much and I really can't recommend it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful