Shockingly terrible narration

I really enjoyed the books but the narration was just awful. The main character sounded super-whiny (which doesnt come across in the paperbacks to such a degree). Binnabick talks like a poor mans yoda and the rimmersmen all talk like schwarzenneger at his dullest.

I bought the memory sorrow and thorn audible series a few years ago now and didnt make it to the end of the first book. The paperbacks were fantastic though. Recently i revisited the audible version thinking it must be just me, but no. Still as terrible as the first time.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Dark without being grimdark

I don't usually read this kind of epic fantasy with the world threatening evil dark lord/god kinda thing anymore but I really enjoyed this. The story can be quite dark and with some creepy horror elements but it doesn't beat you over the head with it all like some of the edgy grimdark stuff tries to do.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Underrated fantasy series

Can’t believe I’d never heard of this series before. It’s epic fantasy at its best. It has the world-shaking forces and deep lore of LotR and the scheming and grit of GoT.

I was cautious after a review said the narration was terrible, but I thought it was perfect. I’ve listened to a lot of series and I would say this was one of the best. Each region has a different accent, and each character has a distinct voice. I actually felt it was better to listen that to have read it l.

I’ve also seen a lot of reviews saying that the beginning is too slow and boring. I really disagree, especially compared to other authors like Tolkien and GRRM. It takes its time to establish all the major players, introduce some lore, and major events takes place before we understand what they mean. I didn’t find myself bored once.

Really loved this book and I can’t wait to continue the series since I’ve heard it gets better and better.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A Visit With An Old Friend.

Where does The Dragonbone Chair rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

The Dragonbone Chair is the first part of a huge series (120+ listening time) the Memory, Sorrow Thorn Sequence. I first read this book in the late 80's or early 90's and it is a series that I would recommend to people who liked fantasy fiction. I decided to revisit the series because I'd heard Tad Williams was writing a new sequence and I wanted to refresh my memory. Andrew Wincott's narration is absolutely fantastic, even though the majority of the book is seen through the eyes of Simon there is a vast array of characters and the narrator uses every trick to make every character no matter the sex, age or race stand out.

Who was your favorite character and why?

I think the character of Simon the mooncalf kitchen boy who deems to be in the right place at the wrong time is a great creation. Tad Williams really gets across the confusion, excitement and wonder that the teenage boy feels as events spiral out of control.

Have you listened to any of Andrew Wincott’s other performances? How does this one compare?

The narration is brilliant. The only other audiobooks that I've heard narrated by Andrew Wincott are the rest of the sequence, and they are equally as good.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Several moments in this book but I was in tears for the last hour of the final book.

Any additional comments?

A fantastic start to a great series of books. I'll look forward to listening to the new book and then the new series when they are released.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A Brilliant Re-Read

Would you consider the audio edition of The Dragonbone Chair to be better than the print version?

You cannot compare the two but the narration is very very good

What was one of the most memorable moments of The Dragonbone Chair?

It's an epic. So too many to mention

Which character – as performed by Andrew Wincott – was your favourite?

I thought he did all of them very well indeed, he is gifted enough to make each of them individual without going over the top with accents and intonation.

Any additional comments?

I read these books years ago and was a little dubious as to how I would perceive them after all this time but the first book was bloody good and so well read by Andrew Wincott - I sincerely hope he is busy narrating the rest of the series. Can't wait to listen to them.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

a great story

loved this book just about to start the next book the green angel hope it's as good

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An interesting setup for a 2nd book..a slow burner

I usually devour most epic fantasy books, funding it hard to stop myself listening/reading and sneaking away to read more. This one tool me alot longer than usual. It was performed very well. The narrator was among the best I've heard but the story (I felt personally) was a little slow in parts. The background info was needed and did enrich the characters and story. I just felt like it had been dragged out at times and could have accomplished more with less.
But as I said in the title this book shouldn't be regarded as a complete work, more an intro into a new world, as nothing truly remarkable happens for the majority of the book (there are some exciting parts though ) but it does leave you with quite a few unanswered and exciting questions and revelations which point to a more engrossing second book.
I think it was worth persevering and it may be one of those series that start slow but turn out to be amazing. I usually mourn those the hardest as by the time your done you don't want the story to be over!
If you have the patience to let it play out and plan to read the whole set of books, then it is definitely worth your time. On its own though you would be left a little frustrated. Clearly a small part of a better whole.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

16 people found this helpful

Didn't think the book could be improved on. It was

read the book ages ago, remembered struggling a bit to keep momentum. this narrator is a master, and does incredibly with a very challenging range of character voices who all seem to have huge, crucial monologues. I will hurry to get the next book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Best quad series

I transversed overseas audible accounts to get this book. I lived in the UK when this book series became available and I paid for an audible uk account until all of them were finally released. There is absolutely nothing poorly conceived, flatly written, or non- recognizable about these characters. This was my favourite fantasy of the 1990’s and it’s still my favourite today. I bought all the damn books in the 90s, and I wore them out. Best fantasy series of the modern age.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

excellent story from a fab author..well narrated

loved this. read the story as a youth and decided to revisit it. just as good seco d time round.

great narration

great tale

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!