Must read for any WoTR fan

I thoroughly enjoyed Garthwaite’s telling of the life of Cecily Neville.

The White Queen was one of the first historical novels I read so it was difficult to put aside Phillipa Gregory’s portrayal of Cecily as an antagonist and go into this with an open mind.

Garthwaite portrays her as a powerhouse of a woman for her day, always at the centre of politics and schemes, with a sharp wit and wicked sense of humour. At times she is just plain wicked too, and more than once I was shocked by her character.

That being said, I also couldn’t help but root for her, and rejoice when things went right, and dismay when things went wrong. By the end I respected her and sympathised with her as a strong woman, a mother, and a wife.

I have only given the story 4 stars as I found the middle portion a bit heavy going with a lot of politics/talk and not a lot of movement in terms of narrative. Also I think that if you haven’t got a good starting knowledge of the main players of the period, it may be a struggle to keep up with the endless Richard’s, Henry’s, Anne’s etc. and their motives.

I thoroughly enjoyed the narration on this audiobook and found it very emotive and evocative of Cecily’s character, which certainly added to the story for me.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Historical backstory: the woman's side

1430s England. Now I've enjoyed The White Queen, other Tudor novels and read non-fiction on Henry VIII and his wives, I do like learning about this period.

So when I partway through this realised the family tree connection to those famous monarchs, I was even more interested, with Cecily being mother to a king who sired kings and queens - her influence would have been felt through those generations.

While this is almost a 'typical' woman's story of the period in some ways - endless pregnancies, births, losses of children and day-to-day menial tasks, Cecily being who she was means this is also the tale of a woman working behind the scenes in the ways she was able to, to influence some very significant events.

Watching her discuss political manoeuvres with her husband, and use her own techniques with other ranking women, and observe them for information, it did show just how much power a woman could yield, if she had skill and the right ear to bend.

I liked this as an audiobook, it brought the slowly ageing voice of Cecily in front of me, the conversation of her tale. The sadness of the life of a woman, its confines, but also how that didn't have to be the case - I very much enjoy seeing the other stories from history we hear less of.

For fans of historical fiction and those who enjoy putting the royal family tree in context.

With thanks to Nudge Books for providing a sample Audible copy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Exciting, emotive, informative and just beautifully written

Can’t say enough good things about this book. I actually binged it in just 2 sittings. It had me gripped from the prologue when I was transported to the execution of Joan of Arc and could almost feel the heat from the fire. So cleverly written, it’s as if the author had witnessed it first hand. Every detail given was so descriptive and not rushed and yet there was no wasted words either. The narrators performance was one of the best I’ve heard on any audiobook and the characters brought to life in a way that absolutely lived up to the authors words. This book was made all the more special as I wasn’t aware that a castle, less than a mile from my home, was once visited and occupied by Cecily and at a point of such importance to her story. I feel like only time separates us from these characters, that we occupy the same place as them and I cannot wait to read this whilst sitting under a tree in the grounds of Maxstoke Castle.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Fascinating history.

Very interesting to hear the history of this period which is not so well known from a woman’s perspective. The performance was good and lively. I enjoyed the book very much.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great story well told

Cecily of York has always fascinated me. She saw her husband and son killed in battle, one son executed by another and two made kings. She was from the house of Beaufort the lineage of John of Gaunt. She must have been a remarkable, strong and dependable women in a time when women supposedly were of no consequence. Not this lady though, but as usual history only speaks of what men did. Great opportunity to read from a different perspective.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great novel, wonderfully read

I love history dramas written from an unusual perspective - this works well, with an authentic voice.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Compelling portrayal of a strong woman

Excellent portrayal of a strong woman and turbulent times. Really enjoyed this rendition of the York struggle for the throne.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great book and narration

A definite must for readers who enjoy this historical period. I slowed the narration down a bit to enjoy the visualisations of the writing and the nuances in some of the dialogue - the narrator was excellent.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Brilliant

A captivating, if we'll known, story told from a different perspective, beautifully read. I could listen to her voice all day!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Gripping and fast paced

A real treat for all fans of historical fiction, and a new perspective on the Wars of the Roses.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!